First, let's adress the elephant in the room. I am the most unreliable blogger ever. My explanation for a near year-long absence is that I have been seduced by microblogging and social networking, of course. In all honesty who knows if I will ever be back here in earnest. Let's see which way the technological winds blow.
But maybe the blog, like the legally purchased CD or DVD is not entirely dead. Maybe it just needs to offer some premiums -- the bonus tracks, the director's commentary -- in order to justify its worth. So, in that vein, here are is the extendo-dance-remix to my recent Facebook post about my Top 25 Songs of the Noughties.
If, freakishly, you are reading this and you are not also my friend on Facebook (really?), here is what I posted:
As a list-making music nerd, this exercise simply had to happen. Who else wants to share a list?
First, my self-imposed rules:
- I limited it to 25 songs. No reason why, except that 10 was impossible; 20 was difficult; and my longer list of 30-plus included -- if I was to be totally honest -- songs that probably didn't need to be there.
- I limited it to one song per artist. This is completely arbitrary, but it seemed a bit more equitable. This added an extra challenge when it came to my defining artists of the Noughties -- like Ad Frank and the Hold Steady to name two -- how to pick just one song? But I did.
- These are in no particular order. That would just be impossible. And besides, in a decade in which "random shuffle" became the dominant paradigm it just seems appropriate.
- I went for a strict interpretation of the Noughties: songs released in 2000 or later. Going against my better instinct, this meant for example not including "Acoustic Guitar" by the Magnetic Fields because it was released in September 1999. I remember in 1989, Rolling Stone named "London Calling," released in December 1979, as the best album of the 80s, which makes complete sense if you think of when it made its cultural impact. But if you are going to go down that route, it opens a big can of worms. For example: should I include "Signed DC" by Love, which was released in 1966, but which made it's "cultural" impact (on me) when I bought it 40 years later?
- I limited my list to music I "own" -- meaning I have it on my hard drive. The only legitimate contender that this ruled out "Yes We Can" by will.i.am. Anything else -- if the song was as good as I like to think, I should have at least made the "effort" to download it.
Next, my observations:
- I am a hopeless sucker for power ballads.
- In the 90s I was obsessed with British music. In the Noughties, a decade I spent mostly in Britain, I seem to have become obsessed with American music. (Or maybe American music was just better. Quite possible.)
- On the one hand, music I discovered more recently has an unfair advantage because I am more likely to remember it. On the other hand, though, it has less time to make an impact.
- I am fairly certain that I only paid for eight of these songs. Talk about a sign of the decade.
- I noted the year next to each song just for informational purposes. In truth, I tended to discover or get introduced to many of these long after they were released. This is would have been different if I had compiled a list at the end of the 90s, a decade in which acquiring music when it was brand new carried much more importance.
- I am somewhat apprehensive about compiling this list with seven weeks remaining in the decade (see "London Calling" issue, above). But really, even if I hear something completely brilliant before the New Year, I am unlikely to believe that it could possibly be decade-defining. Actually, I notice that there is nothing from 2009 here -- but that's not to say I haven't acquired any music this year.
- The most recent song here, Okkervil River's "Blue Tulip" (got it about a month ago, I'm throwing it in on a gamble), and the least recent, "Hold on Hope" by Guided By Voices, sound like they could come from the same album. I think my musical tastes stayed pretty much the same throughout the decade.
On that note, I repeat, in no particular order... the list:
1. Falling - Ben Kweller (2002)
2. Spain - Kristin Hersh (2001)
3. Hold on Hope - Guided By Voices (2000)
4. First Night - The Hold Steady (2006)
5. '59 Sound - Gaslight Anthem (2008)
6. I Love the Unknown - Clem Snide (2000)
7. Time to Pretend - MGMT (2007)
8. Stan - Eminem (2000)
9. Bleeding Heart Show - New Pornographers (2005)
10. The Suffering Song - Willard Grant Conspiracy (2003)
11. Barking Up The Wrong Girl - Ad Frank (2001)
12. Deathly - Aimee Mann (2000)
13. Landlocked Blues - Bright Eyes (2005)
14. Apple of My Eye - Ed Harcourt (2001)
15. Do You Realize - Flaming Lips (2002)
16. A Break in the Clouds - The Jayhawks (2000)
17. See These Bones - Nada Surf (2008)
18. Blue Tulip - Okkervil River (2008)
19. World Inside the World - Rhett Miller (2002)
20. Somerville - Pernice Brothers (2006)
21. The District Sleeps Alone Tonight - The Postal Service (2003)
22. Dry Your Eyes - The Streets (2004)
23. Loyal to My Sorrowful Country - Ted Leo + The Pharmacists (2003)
24. No Cars Go - Arcade Fire (2003)
25. Ms Jackson - Outkast (2000)
There. Discuss.
***
But of course being a true music nerd, the post did not begin there. It needed to be vetted first. I called on my friend Sean for help. The following is our email correspondence:
Wed, 21 October, 2009 22:17:34
From: Alex Maws
To: Sean Smith
Sean,
Inspired by the already-happening end-of-decade lists, I decided to see if I could come up with my own best of the noughties list.I'm going to post it on Facebook at some point, but I thought I would road test it on you, the only other person I know who would engage in such an exercise...
Thoughts? Discuss.(BTW: You may recognise your influence on a few of these...)
[And then I pasted the enire email above, except instead of "Stan" by Eminem I had "Advertising Space" by Robbie Williams; and instead of "I Love the Unknown" by Clem Snide I had "Tears Are In Your Eyes" by Yo La Tengo.]
Fri, 23 October, 2009 19:25:04
From: Sean Smith
To: Alex Maws
Be happy to oblige and I'll get back to you on this asap.
Listen carefully and you can hear the sound of public sector sighs coated with relief... yes, it's half term - to me, a week of respite, to you, a long forgotten and alien concept.
Am I really the only list-mongering-Hornby type you know? That surprises me. Anon...
Sun, 25 October, 2009 14:31:25
From: Alex Maws
To: Sean Smith
Thanks. I'm starting to fret about this. Specifically: should "Mornings Eleven" by the Magic Numbers not have made the list? But instead of what? I suppose that the one most on the cusp would be Arcade Fire, but I would struggle to cut that one.
Moreover, Robbyn, who still remembers things I may have said at the beginning of the decade feels strongly that any list of mine that does not include Eminem's "Stan" is simply fraudulent.
Tue, 27 October, 2009 17:56:57
From: Sean Smith
To: Alex Maws
Alex,
25 is good for me and I was quickly won over by your rationale for it. Btw I like Mornings Eleven [and Stan] but I wouldn't be leaving out Arcade Fire, although my track of distinction varies from yours. No real surprises on your list given what I know about you and your library, although I obviously don't know them all - currently in the process of Spofifying those I don't. In this respect the Facbookees know less than I do, so they're more likely to give you a 'hard time', I guess. I particularly like about half of them [inevitably I concur with a number of your choice of artistes, but would swap the odd selected track], and I pretty much 'like' the remainder though I'm not familiar with about 5 - and this is as it should be, albeit not for long. Didn't know you liked Apple of My Eye to that degree...not that keen on Ms Jackson...not sure how I feel about the Streets but I might review that [see below] and I suppose I'm surprised to see Robbie... All good lists need at least one total surprise.
But that's the thing about lists: in part, they satisfy a want for confirmation of your own good taste, and in part they allow us to redefine/reconstruct our own settled view of something-once-dismissed but which we have now been given the warrant to 'reclaim' anew. Oh, and part I've-never-heard-that-before-but-I-obviously-should-have-and-that-makes me-a-bit-of-loser-but-I'm-ok-with-that-because... now I can either deride its perversity or applaud its brave and judicious inclusion, and perhaps pretend I thought as much all along. Obviously, I jest, in part...
Re: Rules and Observations
Notwithstanding your musings on the impact of the passage-of-time viz decision-making debate, I decided first to consult my itunes 'Top 25 Most Played' list [did you do this...?], because I figured that, so long as I factored in the confounding variables [e.g era dependent-ish, pc listening habits vary compared to other forms etc.,] that this might then provide an empirical basis for the construction of my list. However, I was sadly mistaken - mistaken in the sense that I was disappointed in, and didn't agree with, myself. I guess this is interesting.
This left me wondering about your criteria for track inclusion - it was implicit really, but, in your own words involved the notion of 'decade-defining', which is something I find difficult. However, I guessed that you sort of meant 'liked most' too [most played...] and doubted that you wanted to unduly bemuse the Facebook Nation with this old chestnut of a distinction, or at least not too overtly. Nevertheless, a noughtical and perennial conundrum all the same.
Having said as much, personally, I don't think it's a fight worth having, with yourself or others - in the final [some used to say vinyl] analysis, personal taste wins hands down, regardless of whether or not we want to puff it up into something seminal. For my part, I've never felt catholic enough in my own tastes to assess 'cultural impact' [my list rather proved this point to me...whilst your relative breadth suggests, to some degree, otherwise]. What I would be inclined to say is that we should probably really only just be beginning to compile our 90s list about now...but that wouldn't sell much copy, now would it?
Personally, I made it a rule to include a representative track from each year because it seemed only fair. You didn't actually make this an explicit regulation, though were inclined to more or less observe it [excepting '09], I wasn't clear whether this was by accident or design. I suppose you pay your money and take your choice on this one...
A friend of mine once asked me to compile a tape/soundtrack for a 30th birthday party she was throwing, and the brief was that it should include an 'in-keeping' record from each year of her life. It was an entertaining commission
Finally, on 90s v 00s you certainly would appear more native American since becoming a resident here and, as you suggest, it may just be the result of cyclical phenomena, or, it might perhaps be otherwise construed as the upshot of some musical variation on the greeness of the grass when at home, versus the grass tending toward greener depending upon which side of the Pond your on - Umm...mixed-metaphor-leading-to-loss-of-meaning alert. Whatever, you may just be suffering from that little known condition which is the inverse of going native disorder.
You will see your influence at play in the below. And so, to return the rolling ball, though not to appear on Facebook, and in no particular chronological order...
I Love the Unknown - Clem Snide [1st Jan 2000]
Love Exploded All Around Me [single version] - Bob Schneider [2001]
Apple of My Eye - Ed Harcourt [2001]
Can't Get You Out of My Head - Kylie [2001]
Satellites - Doves [2002]
In Other Words - Ben Kweller [2002
Ribcage - Elbow [2003]
The District Sleeps Tonight - Postal Service [2003]
All My Life - Evan Dando [2003]
Fight Test - Flaming Lips [2003]
Spitting Games - Snow Patrol [2004]
Love Machine - Girls Aloud [2004]
Heliopolis by Night - Aberfeldy [2004]
Rebellion - Arcade Fire [2004]
Eanie Meanie - Jim Noir [2004]
Anecdote - Ambulance Ltd [2005]
Ugly Love - Eels [2005]
Just like the Rain - Richard Hawley [2005]
Mourners of St Pauls - Liam Frost [2006]
Love is a Losing Game - Amy Winehouse [2006]
I-95 - Fountains of Wayne [2007]
We Smash Plates - Absentee [2008]
Why do You Let Me Stay Here? - She&Him [2008]
So Far Around the Bend - The National [2009]
Aicha - The Gellieman [unknown, but sometime in the 00s]
Thu, 5 November, 2009 21:37:18
From: Sean Smith
To: Alex Maws
Did you get my road test? You posted your list yet?
Fri, 6 November, 2009 11:01:59
From: Alex Maws
To: Sean Smith
Hey man,
Sorry to take so long to respond. You've given me a lot to reflect upon here. Plus, I've been in Newcastle. Plus, I've been traumatised by visiting Newcastle.
The postmodern identity-construction strand is one that I could grapple with for days. In the end though, I feel like if I am to be totally honest with myself then yes, I have to admit that this exercise is a sort of superficial self-validating constructionist one. (Or whatever words postmodernists like to throw around these days. "Zeitgeist" maybe?). But I feel like it is mixed with enough genuiness that I can probably still sleep at night. I am actually listening to my list right now (as i thumb-type) on a great new set of headphones, and completely loving it -- as in embarrassing myself by air-drumming on the train type love. So that must speak for something.
The issue about "defining the decade" vs just songs that I "like" is tricky too. I suppose "defining" carries too much weight. What I mean is that these songs in a sense tell a story about the decade (my version of the decade). Not necessarily THE story, or the ONLY story, but A story. A story that at this very early stage I am sticking to. Until it changes.
You're right: Arcade Fire must stay. And in more significant news, Robbyn is also right. She has just won her first ever musical argument with me (I consider the great Posies debate of '04 to be a tie). Eminem is in. Robbie is out. (The final insult to him in an already tough decade. Sorry, mate.)
Now about your list... As you say, any disagreements would just be nitpicking over things that we both know to be worthy. I too will check out the ones I don't know. They're bound to be quality. My one objection is to Clem Snide. I too wanted to include "I Love the Unknown" but Wikipedia assures me it was released in 1999. If you can document something to the contrary, brilliant. But I am hoping you can't because then I don't know what will the next on the chopping block. I might just give up -- or expand the list to 50.
I've not yet posted my list because I couldn't bring myself to do it in October, you know, just in case... But I will do it very soon because I want to allow other people to have time to respond in kind. I actually think I might need to post this entire email exchange on my blog if you are ok with it. It is far more interesting than the list itself!
Over to you.
Alex
Mon, 9 November, 2009 20:16:13
From: Sean Smith
To: Alex Maws
ILtheU: I think Wikip is wrong but I can only provide circumstantial evidence to support my case. I cited 1-1-2000 on my list because I came across this 'precise release date' on some site or other when I was checking myself. Unfortunately, I now can't remember which site this was...
Circumstantially...I bought the physical copy of the single in 2000 and that year is stated on the disc; also, the album from which it is taken [My Favourite Music] came out, according to all sources other than Wikip, in May 2000, which tends to question Wikip's reliability further. On the other hand, there may just be something else going on which I'm not aware of. Really quite surprising that there isn't some authoritative source to verify these things but I couldn't find one.
Impasse. Perhaps I should stick to my story and you to yours...
Sorry to have thrown you into such postmodernist self-validatory handwringing, that wasn't my intention but it was fun while it lasted!
Feel free to blog away. That's fine by me...more than happy
Not surprised you were traumatised by the 'Toon. It's a nation unto itself.
Mon, 9 November, 2009 23:23:13
From: Alex Maws
To: Sean Smith
Hmmm... need to get to the bottom of this. My constructed identity rests on it.
In other news: I have a spare ticket to see Jarvis Cocker play this Wednesday at an art gallery in Shoreditch. You want to join me? I got two tickets on the off chance that someone else might think it sounded as cool as I do.
****
There ends the email chain. NB: Further research revealed that Sean was probably right about Clem Snide, and I made the change to my list.
Feel free to comment with appropriately nerdy things here. Or, of course, just go to Facebook where the discussion is sure to be more lively.

